COTD 5

Elimination
Piplup kills all of the newcomers. He also introduces tokens by giving Ice Bird a win token, killing him in the process. These are the people with votes. If they got in the bottom two, they are in italics.

Pichu

Papyrus

Yoshi

Goom

Black Yoshi

Ice Bird

 Pac Man 

Even though Ice Bird would have gotten eliminated, his 6 votes with the win token suggesting he got 12 votes, it was most likely done for the future episodes. He brings back Pac Man to eliminate him.

Challenge
The next challenge is the same as Season 1s first challenge. Marking the first time a challenge has been reused from a previous episode. Ice Bird wins.

Elimination
Votes:

Goom— 1 vote [Goom]

Tepig— 3 votes [Yoshi, Hoopa, Oshawott]

 Yoshi — 3 votes [Tepig, Ice Bird, Pichu]

Tepig and Yoshi are tied, making them have to fight. Tepig beats Yoshi easily, putting Yoshi in 15th place, and later 22nd place, and later 4th.